You are here: Financial Institutions » Principal-agent problem, part 1: banks
As the financial sector melts down, one wonders which institutions are the safest: smaller local banks, money center banks, super regionals, credit unions. Credit unions are certainly something to think about because they offer high rates of deposit interest and low rates on loans.
I don’t know if credit unions are safer than banks across the board, but I willing to bet they are because they avoid the principal-agent problem.
A ‘credit union’ is described on Wikipedia like this:
A credit union is a cooperative financial institution that is privately owned and controlled by its members. Credit unions differ from banks and other financial institutions in that the members who have accounts in the credit union are the owners of the credit union and they elect their board of directors in a democratic one person-one vote system regardless of the amount of money invested in the credit union.
And therein lies the key advantage of credit unions: they are owned by the members themselves. As a result, they are much more likely to be conservative and there is a much smaller chance of a principal-agent problem.
Much the same dilemma is apparent on Wall Street. Almost all the big Wall Street firms were partnerships owned by their employees. Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Salomon (now a part of Citigroup), and Lehman all went public in the last years. The result has been a massive increase in risk as the principal-agent problem is clear. But, that’s a topic for later.
Wikipedia says this about the principal-agent problem with credit unions:
Credit unions may be viewed as non-profit organizations, or alternatively as for-profit enterprises charged with making a profit for their members (who receive any profits earned by the cooperative in the form of reduced interest rates on loans, or as dividends paid on savings, which are taxed as ordinary income).
This debate reflects credit unions’ unusual organizational structure, which attempts to solve the principal-agent problem by ensuring the owners and the users of the institution are the same people. In any case, credit unions generally cannot accept donations and must be able to prosper in a competitive market economy.
USAA: a credit union-like company
I happen to be a member of the co-operative USAA, which I think is a good example of how these types of organizations work.
They are a AAA-rated full services co-operative that is much like a credit union. Let’s take a look at their financials (PDF), as they have them posted online.
USAA is a member-owned full service financial services company specializing in insurance. Its members are made up exclusively of present and former military personnel and their dependents. It is not publicly traded and issues dividends only occasionally to members in the form of their Subscriber’s Savings Accounts. On the USAA website they describe themselves this way:
The mission of the association is to facilitate the financial security of its members, associates, and their families through provision of a full range of highly competitive financial products and services; in so doing, USAA seeks to be the provider of choice for the military community.
The Value of Membership
USAA is not a publicly traded company, so we don’t answer to stockholders — we answer to our members. They rely on us to suggest products and services that meet their financial needs. In fact, some of our best advice costs absolutely nothing. Advisors in our Financial Advice Center are here to answer questions, large and small, at no charge.
When members join USAA, they join generations of military families who have depended on us to provide superior products and services in an atmosphere of financial strength.
USAA maintains superior ratings from all three of its rating agencies. In fact, it is one of just two U.S. property and casualty companies with the highest ratings from A.M. Best, Moody’s Investors Service, and Standard & Poor’s.
If you look back at my analysis on deleveraging, you’ll note I mentioned that Citibank has a typical bank’s profile at 17x assets to equity. How does that compare to USAA?
USAA had over $67 billion in assets at the end of 2007 on equity of $14.3 billion, a leverage ratio of 5 times. Do they have exposure to CDOs, SIVs and RMBSs? Are they likely to have massive losses from subprime lending? I can’t say. I don’t have comprehensive financials for the company.
I do know they are AAA rated if that means anything anymore. There are fewer than 10 S&P 500 companies that still are AAA-rated in the U.S. because of debt levels. None of the publicly-traded U.S. regionals, none of the money center banks, and none of the global commercial banks can say this. This suggests conservative and cautious, the way bankers used to be.
This rather flimsy analysis doesn’t prove or disprove anything, frankly. But, hopefully, it will give you food for thought about which financial counterparties are trustworthy and which ones may not be. How many times have you heard about credit unions blowing up because of massive exposure to derivatives?
In Australia, credit unions are at risk of demutualising because they operate under financial institutions law rather than co-operative legislation.
I know that many co-operatives in the UK de-mutualised and became public companies, because the money was too much for their shareholders to turn down. (I remember a funny Cold Feet episode where the character David Marsden was talking to his wife about investments and how they had struck it rich in a building society demutualisation scheme — pop culture as a sign of market euphoria). Suddenly, the principal-agent problem was real.
Now, many of those same institutions are in financial trouble because of excessive risk taking over the past years. This includes HBOS (which is a merger of Bank of Scotland and the Halifax, a former mutual company), Bradford and Bingley, Abbey National (now a part of Banco Santander of Spain), and, most famously, Northern Rock.*
Member-owned building societies and credit unions are inherently more risk-averse institutions because they are owned by their members. If one is concerned about the riskiness of the local bank, a member-owned cooperative like a credit union may be the way to go.
As far as demutualisation goes, it’s looking like a bust for shareholders in the UK.
Once there were building societies. Then they became banks, and it all went wrong, The Independent, 7 Jun 2008
B&B and the perils of demutualisation, eFinancial News, 09 Jun 2008
*Personal disclosure: I have a life assurance policy with the Abbey.
About Edward Harrison
Edward Harrison is the founder of Credit Writedowns and a former career diplomat, investment banker and technology executive with over twenty years of business experience. He is also a regular economic and financial commentator on BBC World News, CNBC Television, Business News Network, CBC, Fox Television and RT Television. He speaks six languages and reads another five, skills he uses to provide a more global perspective. Edward holds an MBA in Finance from Columbia University and a BA in Economics from Dartmouth College. Edward also writes a premium financial newsletter. Sign up here for a free trial.
Like us on Facebook
Follow Edward on Twitter
Latest Subscriber Posts
- The so-called new economy and the disintermediation of the rent seekers
- Economic and market themes: 2014-04-21 United States
- Could the US economy accelerate higher in 2014
- Secular versus cyclical factors in equity markets
- Dealing with confirmation bias in macro analysis at market turning points
- Risk for Greece and European periphery from Ukraine crisis escalation mounts
- Economic and market themes: 2014-04-11 – Greece
- Thoughts on Greek bonds, Asian data and resource gamesmanship
- Edward Harrison’s Ten Surprises for 2014, Update 1
- Some thoughts on Ukraine, part 2
- Some thoughts on Ukraine, part 1
- Amazon’s new TV streaming strategy reinforces its incremental approach
- Relief rally in emerging markets
- European, Japanese, and Ukrainian-Russian deflation
- Economic and market themes: 2014-03-28
Recent Blog Posts
- News: 2014-04-22
- Four key reasons for capex accelerating
- ECB Action: Just a Question of Time?
- On Europe’s move toward QE to prevent deflation
- The lower bound of central bank effectiveness
- Ten lessons from Charles Keating on corporatism and control fraud
- On the persistence of inadequate ideas like the money multiplier
- Can the Jobs Data Give the Dollar Another Leg Up?
- The US jobs market is healing
- Jumbos still cheaper than conforming mortgages
- Calm before the Storm?
- Eurozone credit contraction continues
- Emerging Market Equity Allocation Model for Q2 2014
- More Thoughts about Potential for QE from the ECB
- The big disconnect between leverage and spreads
Daily Links Posts
- What do negative interest rates do?
- A Short History Lesson On Ukraine and Crimea
- Economic consequences of income inequality
- The BoE’s sharp shock to monetary illusions
- Marc Faber: China’s Malinvestment Unwind ‘Will Be a Disaster’
- Another Short History Lesson On Russia and Ukraine
- What are the differences between QE1, QE2 and QE3?
- The long decline of the Great British Pound
- Bank reserves and the falling loan to deposit ratio at US banks
- Turmoil in emerging markets: What’s missing from the story?
- How money matters: The Old Lady fails to get an “A”
- The Dummy’s Guide to the US Banking Crisis
- Four signs of economic slowdown in China
- On Europe’s move toward QE to prevent deflation
- The growing mess which will be left behind by the Abenomics experiment
- Chart of the day: US Manufacturing Employment, 1960-2012
- Bitcoin is not a currency
- More on the failure of Abenomics
- Chart of the day: Dow 1928-1932
- Interest rates and deflation
-  No Good Greek Current Account Surplus w/Yanis Varoufakis and Tech w/ Alex Daley
-  Marshall Auerback talks Confidence Game in Europe & Karl Denninger on HFT
-  Big Banks and Political Power with Nomi Prins and Anthony Randazzo
-  Paul Craig Roberts: IMF loans will hand Ukraine over to private banks
-  Tech Market Bubble? with Alex Daley and Howard Lindzon
-  Privatization of Space? and Big Banks in Foreign Policy with Nomi Prins
-  Euro Politics behind Greek Bond Sale w/Yanis Varoufakis & Fed Policy w/Tim Duy
-  Ann Pettifor: Private banks create 95% of UK money
-  Making $$ in the Money Market w/ Marc Chandler and Asian Econ with Daniel Alpert
-  Peter Schiff: It's not the weather, the economy is headed towards recession!